Skip to content
Jupiter Station
  • Home
  • Starfleet
  • Space force
  • Deep space exploration
  • Starfleet shipyards
Space force

Trademark infringement Space Force, Star Trek and Strange New Worlds

Posted on February 13, 2020February 21, 2022 Author Lauren M. Garcia Comments Off on Trademark infringement Space Force, Star Trek and Strange New Worlds

“Given the overall use of the two marks, the fictitious nature of the Starfleet logo and the lack of intent, it is hard to believe that a court would find infringement.”

On January 24, 2020, the United States Space Force logo hit the headlines – and photon torpedoes began flying. Almost instantly, those familiar with the Star Trek Starfleet Command insignia pointed to a striking similarity, and even George Takei (who played USS Enterprise helmsman Hikaru Sulu) tweeted “Ahem. We’re expecting royalties from it…”

Aside from the actual origin of the Space Force insignia (derived from the Air Force Space Command emblem), could anyone really claim that the Space Force emblem is a forgery of mark on the Star Trek logo?

Real versus fictitious clean tables

Let’s start by looking at the Seventh Circuit case of Fortres Grand v. Warner Brothers, which dealt with another variant of the overlap between fiction and reality. As you may recall, from the movie The dark knight rises, Catwoman wants to erase her criminal record from all databases in the world, giving her the chance to resume a normal life. The perfect tool is “the clean slate”, a database hacking program from the Rykin Data Corporation. Rykin himself was fictional, as was the software, but real-world company Fortres Grand actually marketed Clean Slate software to erase user activity from public-access computers.

Fortres Grand sued Warner Brothers for trademark infringement and, on appeal to the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, alleged “reverse confusion”. Fortres claimed that consumers would find Warner Brothers’ use of the “clean slate” name confusing, leading them to believe that the real-world software was tied to the film company. The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals thought otherwise, writing “[w]Whatever these unusually gullible hypothetical consumers are, Fortres Grand has not and could not plausibly allege that consumers are confused by thinking that Fortres Grand is selling such an evil hacking tool under license from Warner Bros. Fortes Grand Corp. against Warner Bros. Ent. Inc., 763 F.3d 696, 705 (7th Cir. 2014).

Given the fictional nature of the software and the fact that the term was only used descriptively in the cinematic dialogues, the court ruled in favor of Warner Brothers. In balancing a fictitious product with a real-world offering, the court said “[t]Trademark law protects the source function of words used in conjunction with goods and services in the marketplace, not the words themselves. Since Warner Brothers offered no real service, and other factors considered in trademark infringement were not strong enough to move the needle, there was no trademark infringement.

The Seven Factor Test

So what about Space Force versus Starfleet? Consider the seven-factor test used by the court in Forts Grand:

  1. the degree of similarity between the marks in appearance and suggestion. Are the two brands alike? Certainly. Regardless of the emblems’ respective histories, there’s certainly a confluence of components and arrangements.
  2. the similarity of the products for which the name is used. Space Force “organizes, trains, and equips space forces to protect U.S. and allied interests in space and provide space capabilities to the joint force. USSF responsibilities include the development of military space professionals, the acquisition of military space systems, the maturation of military doctrine for space power, and the organization of space forces to present to our combatant commands. The Star Trek Emblem, in our real world, may be used to sell certain commercial products, but does not actually provide services related to military space systems, space domain protection, or daring to go anywhere. where off planet earth.
  3. the zone and mode of simultaneous use. The Space Force not only offers the above services. As part of uniform development (and possibly brand marketing), it will offer “branded” clothing, patches, gear for its members and the public, and possibly even toys and games. . (Visit a local PX military base, and you’ll see all of these available items tied to local units and missions.) Given these offerings in the real-world market, the overlap becomes a little clearer.
  4. the degree of caution likely to be exercised by consumers. Are consumers careful in choosing suppliers of space combat power? May be. Buying some cool space-related or Star Trek gear? Maybe not so much. One can easily imagine the accidental gift of a Star Trek hat to the teenager preparing for basic Space Force training.
  5. strength [or “distinctiveness”] of the complainant’s mark. The Space Force logo is brand new, while the Star Trek symbol (or its variants) has been known to the public since the TV show launched in 1966. Is the Starfleet logo distinctive? Certainly.
  6. real confusion. Since the Space Force logo is brand new, there’s probably no real confusion yet. Only time will tell how many of these accidental freebies will be given this year.
  7. an intention on the part of the alleged infringer to pass on his products as those of another. While some cried foul, and others alleged laziness, arguments that Space Force is trying to be perceived as a Starfleet offer are unlikely.

Space Force logo trumps fiction

So, does the new logo infringe when viewed as part of a brand analysis? Unlikely. Given the overall use of the two marks, the fictitious nature of the Starfleet logo and the lack of intent, it is hard to believe that a court would find infringement. That said, the Space Force brand defense may not be as strong as transparent aluminum – only time will tell (unless, of course, George Takei takes us on a slingshot maneuver around the Sun).

Photo by James Creedon

James Credon

is an intellectual property attorney with Creedon PLLC in Frisco, Texas. For more information or to contact James, please visit his company profile page.

Tagged air force, force logo, force space, space command, space force, star trek, states space, united states
Lauren M. Garcia
https://jupiter-station.com

Related Articles

Space force

The US Space Force Explains How Its Logo Doesn’t Scam Star Trek

Posted on July 27, 2020February 6, 2022 Author Lauren M. Garcia

Space Force, a new branch of the US military tasked with the final frontier, unveiled its logo earlier this year, and almost immediately people started comparing it to the Starfleet logo of star trek. And after watching it for half a second, you’ll understand why: The space force logo has no star, while the Starfleet […]

Space force

Dress to impress: US Space Force releases new grooming and uniform guidelines

Posted on June 3, 2022June 4, 2022 Author Lauren M. Garcia

The US Space Force aims to ensure its valiant Guardians are dressed in style with impeccable grooming standards to match their impressive official attire and insignia. The Space Force has implemented a revamped Grooming and Uniform Policy that will ensure that America’s Sixth Military Branch has a distinct style, identity, and culture. As announced in […]

Space force

The US Space Force plans to start patrolling the area around the Moon

Posted on March 3, 2022June 7, 2022 Author Lauren M. Garcia

Enlarge / The US Air Force research laboratory is looking to develop a satellite to patrol cislunar space. US Air Force Research Laboratory This week, the US Air Force Research Lab posted a video on YouTube that didn’t get much attention. But he made a pretty big announcement: The U.S. military plans to expand its […]

Post navigation

The Pentagon is recruiting names for members of the Space Force
Space Force General David Thompson is a Star Trek fan and says don’t join if you want to go to space

Categories

  • Deep space exploration
  • Space force
  • Starfleet

air force branch military deep space donald trump force logo force space military branch sci fi space command space force space operations star trek states space trek discovery united states

Recent Posts

  • Starfleet Innotech Management – GuruFocus.com

  • Space Force Says DARC Software On Track, Following GAO Concerns

  • Global Deep Space Exploration and Technology Market Growth 2022 by Opportunities, Application, Current Trend and Forecast by 2028 – Designer Women

  • 5 Ways Star Trek’s Starfleet Could Absolutely Destroy The Star Wars Empire

  • Business Overview, Industry Snapshot, Upcoming Trends and Top Companies Analysis Report by 2028 – Indian Defense News

Archives

  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • September 2019
  • January 2019
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • March 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • April 2017
  • July 2015
  • March 2015
  • September 2013
  • June 2013
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions